How Alpine forests can continue protecting communities after major disturbances
When a severe windstorm tears through a mountain forest, the immediate aftermath often looks like a complete loss. Thousands of trees lie on the ground, protective forest cover is disrupted, and concerns arise about increased risks from avalanches, rockfall, erosion, and further forest degradation.
But what if those fallen trees can still help protect people and infrastructure long after the storm has passed?
This question is at the heart of the second case featured in FoRISK’s Forest Watch campaign, contributed by Leon Bührle and Dr. Michaela Teich from the Austrian Research Centre for Forests (BFW), which is a member of the International Union of Forest Research Organizations (IUFRO) and part of the FoRISK Observer network. The case also contributes to the work of IUFRO’s Working Party on Snow and Avalanches, which is coordinated by Dr Michaela Teich.
Mountain forests across the Alps perform a vital protective function. They can reduce the hazards associated with snow avalanches, stabilize slopes, intercept falling rocks, and protect settlements, roads, and other infrastructure. However, large disturbances such as windstorms and bark beetle outbreaks can suddenly remove standing trees and create concerns about a reduction in these protective services.
The case focuses on five disturbed mountain forest sites in the European Alps:
- Franza and Col di Lana (Veneto, Italy)
- Kals am Großglockner (East Tyrol, Austria)
- Caore and Molina (Trentino, Italy)
Three of these sites were heavily affected by Storm Vaia in 2018, while the other two experienced severe bark beetle outbreaks. Before the disturbances, the forests were dominated by Norway spruce, with silver fir and European larch present at some locations.
Following the disturbances, different management approaches had been applied at the sites. Some areas were largely left untouched, while others underwent varying degrees of deadwood removal, crosscutting, or retention of root plates. This provided an opportunity to compare how different post-disturbance management strategies were associated with the remaining protective effect of lying deadwood against snow avalanche release.
Looking at protective effects from above
To better understand these effects, researchers from BFW worked together with the University of Padua and other partners within the Interreg Alpine Space project MOSAIC to develop an innovative open-source decision support tool.
The tool combines high-resolution UAV data, digital terrain models, and spatial analysis to assess how:
- lying deadwood, including
- root plates;
- remaining standing trees;
- terrain conditions; and
- increasing snow depth
influence spatial indicators of snow avalanche release potential.
Using drone imagery and laser scanning, researchers were able to map post-disturbance forest structures in remarkable detail and evaluate how much deadwood-related surface roughness remained under increasing snow depth across different management strategies. The approach provides forest managers with a reproducible and evidence-based method for spatially assessing post-disturbance protective effects against snow avalanche release.
Can deadwood continue to protect?
One of the most important findings was that fallen trees can retain an important protective role against snow avalanche release.
Lying stems, root plates, and other deadwood structures increase surface roughness on slopes. This can limit the formation of continuous weak layers in the snowpack and reduce snow avalanche release potential. However, not all deadwood arrangements provide the same level of protection.
The study compared how quickly increasing snow depth reduced this deadwood-related protective roughness under different management strategies. The researchers compared the snow depth required for the selected roughness indicator to reach a standardized reference value of 0.5. Higher snow depths at this reference value indicate that deadwood-related surface roughness persists under deeper snow and therefore suggest a stronger roughness-based protective effect. The reference value allows sites and management strategies to be compared consistently.
The results were clear:
- In completely cleared areas, snow rapidly smoothed the limited residual surface roughness, and the reference value was reached at around 0.2 meters of snow.
- In areas where widely spaced root plates remained, the reference value was reached at around 0.4 meters.
- Following crosscutting and approximately 50% deadwood removal, the reference value was reached at around 1.2 meters.
- In crosscut areas where deadwood remained in place, the reference value was reached at around 1.5 meters.
- In largely uncleared windthrow areas, the reference value was reached at approximately 1.6 to 2.4 meters of snow, depending on the local deadwood structure.
These findings demonstrate that retained deadwood can maintain a forest’s protective effect under substantially deeper snow than heavily cleared terrain.
The research also revealed that the protective effect is not determined solely by how much deadwood remains.
The height, orientation, spatial distribution, stacking of stems, and presence of large root plates all influence how effectively deadwood continues to provide protection under increasing snow depth. At the investigated sites, heterogeneous arrangements created stronger protective effects than more uniform accumulations.
This insight is particularly important for forest managers considering how to balance competing priorities such as forest regeneration, biodiversity conservation, bark beetle management, accessibility, safety, and economic considerations.
Supporting better decisions after major disturbances
The project was not designed to prescribe a single management solution. Instead, it aimed to improve the quality of information available to decision-makers. Before this tool was developed, assessments often relied largely on field observations and expert judgment, making it difficult to compare management options consistently across large and complex mountain landscapes.
Today, the decision-support tool allows practitioners to:
- Map protective-effect indicators across entire slopes.
- Quantitatively compare different deadwood-retention strategies.
- Assess changes in deadwood-related protective effects under increasing snow depth.
- Combine spatial evidence with field expertise and local protection needs.
Repeated UAV monitoring also showed that substantial roughness-based protective effects persisted for years. At two of the monitored sites, roughness-based protective indicators decreased by only about 9% and 15% during the first four years covered by monitoring, suggesting that uncleared windthrow areas can continue providing meaningful protection during the recovery phase.
What Europe can learn
This case demonstrates how innovative technologies and international cooperation can help forest managers make more informed decisions in increasingly disturbance-prone landscapes.
Three key lessons emerged:
- Retain protective deadwood structures where conditions allow. Deadwood can provide a protective effect against snow avalanche release after windthrow and bark beetle disturbances. Its removal should therefore not be automatic, particularly in protective mountain forests.
- Structure matters, not only volume. The height, orientation, stacking, and spatial distribution of logs and root plates can be as important as the total amount of deadwood retained.
- Combine remote sensing with local expertise. Drone-based assessments provide objective and reproducible evidence, but they should complement field knowledge, hazard assessments, regeneration objectives, and local management priorities.
Forest Watch
This Forest Watch case illustrates how members of the FoRISK Observer Organizations like IUFRO are advancing practical solutions for forest risk management across Europe. Through the work of the Austrian Research Centre for Forests (BFW) and its partners, forest managers now have access to an open-source tool for assessing how disturbed mountain forests continue to protect people and infrastructure against snow avalanche release, even after major windstorms and bark beetle outbreaks.
As climate change increases the frequency and severity of forest disturbances and adds to the risks facing European forests, evidence-based approaches such as this will become increasingly important for building resilient forests and communities across Europe.
To learn more, read the scientific article “A spatially explicit UAV-based decision support tool to assess the protective effect of lying deadwood on snow avalanche release”: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2026.115505
The open-source tool can be accessed on Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20310528


